Top 5 Best Cat Food For Picky Cats In 2023





Photo of author

Robert Taylor

Often, cats may reject their food due to their dislike of its smell, taste, or consistency. However, these selective eating habits occasionally indicate an underlying problem. Regardless, when you’re in the market for new cat food, it’s beneficial to grasp the elements that influence your cat’s taste. 

This comprehensive guide will delve into the factors that impact a cat’s food preferences and the typical reasons for food refusal. Additionally, we’ve provided thorough reviews of our top 10 best cat food for picky cats.

Let’s check it out now!

This post contains affiliate links. Read more here.
Not a substitute for professional veterinary help.

Best Overrall

Wellness CORE Tiny Tasters Wet Cat Food Topper

  • Grain-free and complete, balanced nutrition

  • No-mess pouches for convenient serving

  • Variety pack with exciting seafood flavours

Best Overrall

Best for Flavour

Fussie Cat Market Salmon Meal Formula

  • Rigorous daily quality inspections ensure safety and purity

  • Offers peace of mind for cat owners who want the best for their pets

Best for Budgets

Iams Healthy Enjoyment Dry Cat Food Chicken

  • Real chicken is the #1 ingredient

  • Balanced nutrition with 0% fillers

Best for Nutrients

Tiki Pets Tiki Cat Velvet Mousse Grain-Free

  • Silky-smooth texture

  • Grain-free for sensitive stomachs

  • Value for money in a 12-pack

Best for Pack Variety

Purina Fancy Feast Gravy Lovers Poultry

  • Rich and savory gravy that cats adore

  • Keeps cats well-hydrated

  • Exciting mealtime experience for your cat

Top 5 Best Cat Food For Picky Cats













#1 Wellness CORE Tiny Tasters Wet Cat Food Topper – Best overall

Editor’s Ratings:

Brand: Wellness | Form: Wet | Flavors: Sea Variety Pack | Life Stage: Adult

What We Liked:

– Grain-free and complete, balanced nutrition;
– Real meat ingredients for a delectable taste;
– No-mess pouches for convenient serving;
– Variety pack with exciting seafood flavours;
– Perfect portion size for use as a topper or standalone treat.

What We Didn’t Like:

– Limited flavour options if your cat prefers non-seafood varieties.

Product Highlights

I recently had the chance to explore Wellness CORE Tiny Tasters Wet Cat Food Toppers and let me tell you, it’s been quite the adventure for my furry friend! If you want to take your cat’s dining experience to the next level, this seafood variety pack is a fantastic choice.

From my experience, I’ve found that Wellness CORE Tiny Tasters truly lives up to its promise of being grain-free and delivering complete, balanced nutrition. My cat can be quite picky, but mealtime has become a breeze with these no-mess pouches.

The variety pack is a hit in our household because it features an array of flavours that keep our cat excited for mealtime. It includes delightful options like Tuna and salmon, Tuna & Shrimp, and Shredded Chicken and chicken Liver. The real meat ingredients in these toppers make every meal a delectable experience for our furry family members.

Our verdict

This product offers your feline friend a convenient, nutritious, and delicious dining solution. Real meat ingredients and various seafood flavours make it a top choice to elevate your cat’s mealtime experience.

#2 Fussie Cat Market Salmon Meal Formula – Best for Flavor

Editor’s Ratings:

Brand: Fussie Cat | Form: Dry | Flavors: Salmon Formula | Life Stage: All Life Stages

What We Liked:

– High-quality ingredients produced in an FDA-registered kitchen;
– Rigorous daily quality inspections ensure safety and purity;
– Formulated to meet AAFCO cat food nutrient profiles for all life stages;
– Contains a salmon meal, a favourite flavour for many cats;
– Offers peace of mind for cat owners who want the best for their pets.

What We Didn’t Like:

– Price may be higher compared to some other cat food brands.

Product Highlights

Fussie Cat Market Salmon Meal Formula is an exceptional choice to provide your feline friend with top-quality nutrition. I’ve explored and tested various cat food options, and Fussie Cat stands out for all the right reasons.

From my experience, their commitment to quality sets Fussie Cat apart. They produce their foods in an FDA-registered kitchen, which is used for producing human-grade canned foods. This means you’re giving your beloved cat a meal that meets the same standards as food fit for people to eat. That level of quality assurance is a reassuring aspect that cat owners can truly appreciate.

What I find particularly impressive is their rigorous quality inspections. Daily checks for food safety, heavy metals, pathogens, contamination, and pesticides ensure that the end product is not just good but exceptional. As a cat owner, knowing that your pet’s food is thoroughly vetted for safety and quality gives you peace of mind.

Our verdict

It is a top-quality choice for cat owners who prioritise the well-being and safety of their feline companions. While it may come at a slightly higher price, the assurance of FDA-registered production, rigorous quality inspections, and a formula meeting AAFCO standards make it a premium option worth the investment.

#3 Iams Healthy Enjoyment Dry Cat Food Chicken – Best Budgets

Editor’s Ratings:

Brand: Iams | Form: Dry | Flavors: Chicken & Beef | Life Stage: Adult

What We Liked:

– Real chicken is the #1 ingredient;
– Balanced nutrition with 0% fillers;
– Irresistible taste for picky eaters;
– Supports whole body health with essential nutrients and antioxidants;
– 2X the antioxidants for healthy immunity.

What We Didn’t Like:

– Specific flavour options.

Product Highlights

If you’ve got a finicky feline at home, you know the constant struggle to find the perfect cat food that piques their interest and nourishes them. Look no further because I’ve recently had the pleasure of testing Iams Healthy Enjoyment Dry Cat Food in the Chicken & Beef Recipe, and I must say, it’s a winner in every aspect!

The first thing that caught my attention is that the number one ingredient in this cat food is real chicken. That’s a big win for me because it ensures my kitty gets the protein she needs for her overall well-being. It’s not just a treat; it’s nutritious and vital.

What sets Iams apart is its perfect balance of taste and nutrition. Iams Healthy Enjoyment combines irresistible flavours with complete and balanced nutrition. This is a game-changer for those picky eaters in your life. My cat loves the crunchy, tasty bites with that soft, flavorful filling. It’s like a gourmet meal for her every day!

Our verdict

 With real chicken as the primary ingredient, balanced nutrition, and a flavour that even picky eaters adore, it’s a winner. The added antioxidants and digestive support make it a comprehensive option for your feline friend’s health.

#4 Tiki Pets Tiki Cat Velvet Mousse Grain-Free – Best for Nutrients

Editor’s Ratings:

Brand: TIKI PETS | Form: Wet | Flavors: Tuna & Chicken | Life Stage: All Life Stages

What We Liked:

– Silky-smooth texture;
– High-quality, real ingredients (e.g., tuna and chicken);
– Suitable for both adult cats and kittens;
– Grain-free for sensitive stomachs;
– Convenient 2.8oz cans;
– Value for money in a 12-pack.

What We Didn’t Like:

– May be relatively more expensive compared to some other cat food options.

Product Highlights

Look no further if you’re a cat owner looking to pamper your furry friend with a nutritious and indulgent meal.

From my experience, I’ve found that Tiki Cat Velvet Mousse is not just your typical cat food; it’s a culinary delight for your beloved pet. The silky-smooth texture is what sets it apart. It’s like fine dining for your cat, with a gourmet touch that your feline friend will appreciate.

I recommend the Tuna & Chicken flavour – it’s a winning combination my cat couldn’t resist. We opened a can and immediately noticed the high-quality ingredients. The real shreds of tuna and chicken are a testament to the product’s commitment to premium ingredients. From my exploration, I discovered that this grain-free wet food is perfect for adult cats and kittens, making it a versatile option for households with multiple feline companions of varying ages.

Our verdict

Tiki Pets Tiki Cat Velvet Mousse Grain-Free Wet Food is a high-quality option that elevates your cat’s dining experience. Its silky-smooth texture, premium ingredients, and suitability for both adult cats and kittens make it a top choice.

#5 Purina Fancy Feast Gravy Lovers Poultry – Best for pack variety

Editor’s Ratings:

Brand: PURINA Fancy Feast | Form: Wet | Flavors: Poultry & Beef | Life Stage: Adult

What We Liked:

– Rich and savory gravy that cats adore;
– Variety pack with 24 cans, offering different flavors;
– High-quality ingredients;
– Keeps cats well-hydrated;
– Exciting mealtime experience for your cat.

What We Didn’t Like:

– Cans are relatively small (3 ounces each).

Product Highlights

First and foremost, let me tell you about the variety in this pack. You get 24 cans, each 3 ounces, filled with delectable poultry and beef flavours. This is a fantastic assortment that keeps mealtime exciting for your furry companion. My cat couldn’t be happier with the options provided.

What truly sets this cat food apart is the rich, savoury gravy. Cats adore it, and watching them savour every drop is a joy. The texture is perfect, not too thick or thin, and my cat seems to enjoy every lick. This gravy-laden formula keeps my cat well-hydrated, which is a big plus.

Now, let’s talk about the quality of the ingredients. Purina Fancy Feast is known for its high-quality selections; this product is no exception. I explore a variety of cat food brands, and when it comes to ingredient lists, Purina Fancy Feast always stands out. It’s reassuring that my cat is getting a gourmet meal made with care.

Our verdict

The Purina Fancy Feast Gravy Lovers Poultry and Beef Gourmet Wet Cat Food Variety Pack is a delightful choice for cat owners. Its rich gravy, high-quality ingredients, and variety make it a top-notch option for keeping your cat happy and satisfied during mealtime.

Why Do Cats Develop Selective Eating Habits?

Cats can exhibit finicky eating behaviours for various reasons, encompassing instincts, behaviours, and health considerations. Here are some potential rationales for their choosy approach to food:

Certain cats may like certain flavours, textures, or odours based on their natural inclinations.

Cats can be discerning eaters, displaying surprising selectivity in their diet. Cats have a highly discriminating palate, with only 470 taste buds compared to a human’s 9,000. Consequently, your cat may reject food that fails to entice their taste buds or lacks nutritional value.

Buying Guide

Selecting the most appealing cat food can be overwhelming, especially when humans aren’t fond of pet food. If your cat has never shown disinterest in food before, understanding the potential reasons can assist you in determining where to begin when searching for food they will eat.


Cats, like humans, can get tired of repeatedly eating the same thing. Feeding your cat the same food for an extended period, especially if they are a picky eater, can lead to boredom. Variety packs are a popular solution, allowing you to switch between flavours and keep your cat engaged. It’s also advisable to introduce different flavours periodically to prevent your finicky feline from becoming bored.

Wrong Texture

Cat food, like human food, comes in various textures, from crunchy to smooth and from shredded to chunky. Cats have texture preferences that can change with their mood or how frequently they eat the same type of food. They might want something chewy instead of crunchy occasionally.

Wrong Temperature

Cats’ food preferences can be influenced by temperature. They might not enjoy a warm meal on a hot day or a cold one on a chilly day. Cats prioritise comfort, so they may turn away from food that doesn’t align with their preferred temperature.


Cats, like humans, can lose their appetite due to stress. Routine disruptions, such as a house move or a vet visit, can affect their eating habits. Abrupt changes in their diet can also cause stress. Following the feeding transition instructions on cat food packets can help ease this transition.

Not Hungry

Sometimes, a cat simply isn’t hungry, especially if it’s an indoor cat that requires less energy than outdoor cats. They may prefer to nap rather than eat at the moment. Outdoor cats might be finding food elsewhere.

Health Problems

If all other possibilities have been ruled out, your cat’s decreased appetite could be due to an underlying health issue. In such cases, you should consult a veterinarian to determine if your cat is suffering from an illness.

Foods & Flavors To Avoid For Picky Cats

For picky cats, finding foods that they enjoy and are safe for their consumption can be quite challenging. While some cats may be more selective in their eating habits, it’s crucial to be aware of certain human foods that should be avoided entirely to ensure your feline friend’s well-being. Here’s a detailed list of foods to avoid for picky cats:


Chocolate is a definite no-no for cats. It contains theobromine and caffeine, both of which are toxic to cats. Even a small amount of chocolate can lead to symptoms like vomiting, diarrhea, increased heart rate, muscle tremors, and in severe cases, seizures. So, never share your chocolate treats with your cat, no matter how much they beg.


Contrary to popular belief, many cats are lactose intolerant, and giving them milk can lead to digestive issues. While the image of a cat sipping milk from a saucer is common, it’s not a good idea. Consuming milk can cause diarrhea in cats due to their inability to properly digest lactose, potentially leading to dehydration.


Avocado is another food to steer clear of for your cat. It contains a substance called persin, which harms many animals, including cats. Ingesting avocado can result in vomiting and diarrhea in cats, which is highly unpleasant for you and your picky feline friend.

Onions and Garlic

Whether raw or cooked, onions and garlic are highly toxic to cats; they contain compounds that can lead to severe health issues, including damage to red blood cells. 

Ingesting these can cause the red blood cells in a cat’s body to rupture or become less efficient at carrying oxygen. This can result in anemia and other serious complications, making avoiding dishes seasoned with these ingredients crucial.

Raisins or Grapes

Both raisins and grapes are toxic to cats and should never be given to them. Consumption of these fruits can lead to kidney failure in cats, a life-threatening condition. Even a small amount can be dangerous, so keeping these foods far away from your picky eater is essential.


Can I make homemade cat food for my picky cat?

While making homemade cat food possible, ensuring it meets all of your cat’s nutritional needs can be challenging. Consult with a veterinarian or feline nutritionist before attempting homemade cat food.

How can I transition my picky cat to a new food?

Gradual transitions are essential. Mix a small amount of the new food with the old food and slowly increase the proportion of the new food over several days or weeks to prevent digestive upset.

What should I do if my picky cat refuses to eat altogether?

If your cat refuses to eat for more than 24 hours, consult your veterinarian immediately. Prolonged lack of food can be harmful, and there may be an underlying medical issue that needs attention.

How can I tell if my cat’s pickiness is a sign of a health problem?

If your cat’s pickiness is a sudden behaviour change, it’s a good idea to consult your vet. Changes in appetite can sometimes signal underlying health issues that need professional evaluation.


Choosing the best cat food for picky cats is essential to ensure their health and happiness. With a wide range of options, it’s important to consider your cat’s preferences and dietary needs. 

If you are wondering about the best product for overalls, Wellness CORE Tiny Tasters Wet is worth a try for picky cats.

In contrast, Iams Healthy Enjoyment Dry Cat Food will be more suitable for your tight budget.

Doing so lets you find the perfect food to keep your finicky feline satisfied and well-nourished.

Recommended Reading

Share on:

Robert Taylor

I love cats, I have more than 10 years of experience in raising cats. I want to share with everyone useful knowledge about cats.

Robert Taylor